Payroll has a rhythm most of the year: pay the team, make the deposits, file the quarterly returns. Then December shows up and piles on bonuses, raises, year-end forms and every contractor you forgot to collect paperwork from.
Most year-end payroll headaches aren’t December problems. They’re fall decisions that didn’t get made. Here are five to settle now.
1. Decide on bonuses before the holidays decide for you
A year-end bonus is taxable wages. It gets federal and state income tax withholding plus Social Security and Medicare, and you pay the employer share of those payroll taxes on top. A $1,000 bonus costs the business more than $1,000, and your employee takes home less than that.
None of that is a reason to skip bonuses. It’s a reason to pick the number now, so it’s already in your cash flow plan and your tax projection when the check goes out.
2. Put January raises into the system early
If raises start January 1, the budget conversation, the paperwork and the pay-rate changes in your payroll software all have to happen in the fourth quarter. A new rate entered in a hurry is how a raise gets missed on the first check of the year, or applied to the wrong person.
3. Get a W-9 from every contractor you paid this year
Every independent contractor you paid in 2026 should have a Form W-9 on file before 1099 season. The reporting threshold changed for payments made in 2026, so don’t assume last year’s rule still applies. Ask us which of your contractors need a form.
Chasing a W-9 from a contractor who finished the job in March is a January chore nobody wants. Collect them now.
4. Get ready for the new overtime line on W-2s
This one is new this year. Under the One Big Beautiful Bill, many employees can deduct part of their overtime pay on their personal return. Starting with 2026 wages, employers have to report qualified overtime separately on each employee’s W-2, in box 12 with code TT.
In practice your payroll records need to separate the overtime premium from regular pay for every nonexempt employee, for the whole year. If your system has been lumping it together, it’s far easier to fix now than in late January. We covered the rest of the law in What You Need to Know about the One Big Beautiful Bill.
5. Check your setup before it carries into next year
Business owners set up payroll and sales tax once, when the business is new, and then rarely look at them again. Rates change, employees move, and pay structures shift as you grow. Year-end is a good time to confirm your sales tax and payroll setup still fits the business you have now, not the one you started with. If you’re just getting started, our business startup services cover payroll setup from day one.
For more on keeping payroll accurate as your team grows, read Streamlining Payroll Processing for Growing Local Businesses.
Let us take payroll off your desk
We process payroll, make the federal deposits, file Forms 941 and 940, and prepare W-2s for small businesses across Stow, Cuyahoga Falls and Summit County. Because payroll ties straight into bookkeeping, your books and your payroll tell the same story at year-end.
See our payroll services, or call 330-686-6666 to set up a year-end payroll review. An hour now beats a bad week in January.